Controversial Penalty Decision in Arsenal vs Newcastle Match
Controversy Surrounds Arsenal's Penalty Decision Against Newcastle
Arsenal's match against Newcastle at St. James' Park was once again marked by controversy. The latest incident occurred in the 14th minute when the Gunners were awarded a penalty, only for the decision to be overturned following a review by the video assistant referee (VAR).
A misplaced backpass from Newcastle's Jacob Murphy was intercepted by Arsenal striker Viktor Gyokeres, who was subsequently brought down by goalkeeper Nick Pope. Referee Jarred Gillett initially pointed to the penalty spot, but after reviewing replays that indicated Pope had made contact with the ball, he was called to the pitchside monitor for a second look.
Upon review, Gillett reversed his decision, stating, "After review, the Newcastle goalkeeper plays the ball and there is no foul. The final decision is a drop ball." This decision sparked protests from the Arsenal players.
While it appeared that Pope did make contact with the ball, the question remains: was that sufficient to rule out a penalty?
Understanding the Rules
According to the International Football Association Board (IFAB) Law 12.1, a direct free kick is awarded if a player commits certain offenses against an opponent in a manner deemed careless, reckless, or using excessive force. These offenses include charging, jumping at, kicking, pushing, striking, tackling, or tripping an opponent.
If contact occurs, a direct free kick is warranted. The definitions are as follows:
Careless: A lack of attention or consideration when making a challenge, requiring no disciplinary action.
Reckless: Acting with disregard for the safety of an opponent, warranting a caution.
Excessive Force: Exceeding the necessary force, endangering an opponent's safety, leading to a potential dismissal.
Pundits Weigh In
Opinions among pundits regarding the penalty decision were mixed:
Gary Neville, former Manchester United defender: "Viktor Gyokeres kicks it against Nick Pope's feet. Pope still blocked Gyokeres. I’m definitely torn. Nick Pope does get a touch, which is usually the barometer for referees regarding penalties."
Pat Nevin, former Chelsea midfielder: "I have to be honest, the VAR has looked at it, and the referee has looked at it. Yes, he got a touch on it, but he still took out the player. I'm viewing it from the forward's perspective."
Joe Hart, former Manchester City goalkeeper: "If Pope touches the ball, then it’s not a penalty - and he does touch it before he hits Gyokeres. The decision is understandable when broken down."
Jamie Redknapp, former Liverpool midfielder: "He gets a touch, but I’m not sure it’s enough to negate the foul. I’m surprised it got overturned."
Les Ferdinand, former Newcastle striker: "It’s a great touch. Once the goalkeeper gets a touch and deviates the ball, it’s not a penalty. I don’t know what Pope could do there."
This article is brought to you by BBC Sport's Ask Me Anything team.
What is Ask Me Anything?
Ask Me Anything is a service dedicated to addressing your questions. We aim to reward your time by sharing new insights and reminding you of key information. Our team will provide answers, leveraging a network of experts and pundits, while offering behind-the-scenes access to major sporting events. Our coverage will be available across the BBC Sport website, app, social media, YouTube, and BBC TV and radio.