The Evolution of the Premier League: A Manager's Perspective
The quality of the Premier League is a topic of ongoing debate, with discussions centering on whether it is better now than it was 10 or 20 years ago.
Media and fans often evaluate the league based on the quality and excitement of the football compared to a decade ago. As a former manager, I would like to share my perspective on this matter.
What are your thoughts on your team's performances? Are you witnessing a more cultured, possession-based style today compared to the past, or do you feel your team lacks the drive and commitment seen in previous years?
My assessment is not solely based on performance or style; it also considers the significant changes that have occurred off the pitch.
When you visit most stadiums today, whether as a supporter, manager, or player, the impressive facilities are undeniable. Our stadiums and training grounds are now among the best in the world, featuring top-notch fitness and medical centers, and perfectly maintained pitches.
However, has everything improved? Opinions will vary, but from a managerial viewpoint, certain aspects are crucial.
Owners - A Dream Relationship for Some
Throughout my career managing ten clubs, I worked with eight chairmen who were local owners. They understood the club's significance to the community and fostered a close relationship with supporters.
My strong connections with these individuals allowed for open discussions about the club's development, especially during challenging times. This relationship is vital at any club, but it remains a dream for many managers today.
Most Premier League and several Championship clubs now have owners and investors based abroad, where football is viewed as a business. For these stakeholders, profitability often takes precedence over sporting success, making it challenging for managers to engage in meaningful discussions about football.
As a result, various roles such as sporting directors and directors of football have emerged, further limiting direct communication between managers and owners. If I were still managing today, I would prefer a setup similar to those at clubs like Brighton, Brentford, Stoke, Middlesbrough, and Bristol City, where owners have a personal understanding of the local community.
Academies - Cash Cows or Development Hubs?
I often hear fans proudly proclaiming, "he's one of our own," in reference to home-grown talent making it to the first team. The academy system in this country has a strong appeal, with young players joining as early as six years old and spending significant time in the academy.
These young players often develop a deep connection with their clubs and coaches. As someone who remembers the West Ham players who helped England win the World Cup in 1966, I understand the pride in home-grown talent.
Unfortunately, today's academy players are increasingly viewed through a commercial lens. Clubs have recognized the profit potential in selling academy players, often sacrificing top talent to meet financial sustainability goals.
Moreover, clubs are investing heavily in foreign talent for their academies. Is this a strategic football decision or merely a financial safety net?
Playing Styles - The Fashion of Football
Since Pep Guardiola's arrival at Manchester City nine years ago, a particular style of play has become the standard, influencing coaches across all levels of the game.
While Manchester City undoubtedly had the strongest squad in the Premier League at that time, many managers began prioritizing style over substance, often enforcing possession-based football regardless of their team's strengths.
While I have always tailored my approach to my squad's capabilities, I admire the revolution that Pep and City have initiated. Possession football can be thrilling to watch, but not when it devolves into aimless passing.
In my early days, we were taught to move the ball forward to our most skilled players. Football should be adaptable, not rigidly defined by a single style.
Fashions in football continue to evolve; set plays have become increasingly popular, with teams now employing long throws and varied corner strategies. Perhaps we are witnessing a shift back toward prioritizing effectiveness over style. As a manager, my focus has always been on achieving results, and it seems that the Premier League may be moving in that direction now.
Tony Pulis was speaking to BBC Sport's Chris Bevan.